Click any page to read it larger.
THE WIT OF MOUNT STREET;
or,
HER HEART IN NUMBERS.
(Continued from page 284.)
CHAPTER XV.
On Value.
In which a book is lent and not given, three fields are made to feed a country, a gentleman crosses forty feet of Albemarle Street, a house in Manchester stops, and the pestilence is called as a witness.
On the Monday he brought a book.
He had it on the bench beside him when she came down the gravel from the gate, at twenty past three, in the dyed gown: a fat octavo in grey boards, the paper label rubbed, with a sharp edge of white slips standing out of the top of it like teeth. He left it where it lay when she sat down, and she appeared not to look at it. Toby, on the coping of the river wall with his back to the two of them, had already taken out his own book and was drawing the water; and for some time the three of them sat in the Inner Temple garden and attended to their several occupations, as people do who have met in a public place by chance.
“You are looking at my book,” said Mr. Kinross.
“I am looking at the river.”
“You are looking at my book out of the side of your bonnet. It is a thing I have learnt to see.” He laid his hand on it. “It is the only book from Albemarle Street that I have never been able to finish.”
“From your Albemarle Street?”
“From the other side of it. The Albemarle’s door is on one side of the street, and Mr. Murray’s is on the other. This is Murray’s.” He turned it so that she could read the label. Principles of Political Economy and Taxation. “By Mr. Ricardo. The second edition. I bought it at Hatchard’s last winter, because everybody at the Temple was quarrelling about it at dinner, and I like to know what a man is being abused for before I abuse him. I read the first chapter. I read it three times. On the third time I made a
mark in the margin, and the mark was a question; and I have not opened it since.”
“What were they quarrelling about?”
“Corn,” said Mr. Kinross. “Whether the price of bread in London is kept up for the sake of the landlords, and whether that is wicked or merely Tory. Pelham says Mr. Ricardo has proved that every landlord in England is a thief. Mr. Grice says he has proved nothing of the kind, and that he is a stockbroker. I did not get far enough to know which of them was right.” He considered the river. “I am a landlord myself, in Scotland, in what I believe is a small way. I have never looked. I found I did not want to know very much.”
“Then why have you brought it?”
He was silent a moment.
“Because you will finish it,” he said. “And I should like to know what is in it.”
She took it then. It was heavier than it looked. She opened it at the first chapter, which was called On Value, and saw his pencil going down the margin of the first pages: a stroke here, a tick there, a word she could not read. She had watched that pencil move once, in August, on a bench, and had never seen what it wrote. On the twentieth page the marks thinned. On the twenty-second there was a single ques
tion mark, small and upright, against a sentence about the labour bestowed on commodities; and after that the margins were clean.
She thought of his pencil. He had given it to Toby on the river wall in March, and Toby had told her what Mr. Kinross said when he gave it: that he had done marking things. She kept the thought to herself.
“You may keep it,” said Mr. Kinross.
“No.”
“I have no use for it. I have proved that.”
“Lend it me,” said Clemency. “I will give it back. I do not take presents, Mr. Kinross. I have never been able to afford them.”
He looked at her, and the place at the corner of his mouth moved: the place she had once laid her mother’s carmine on, in a drawing of his face, and been ashamed of for a week.
“Lend it, then,” he said. “For as long as you like. I shall not ask for it.”
“You will ask for it,” said Clemency, “the day I have finished it, because you will want to know whether I agree with him. And I shall tell you.”
She put it under her arm with the London. It made her lean a little to one side going back up the gravel, and the old Bencher, who was coming down it, observed that the young person had been to a library and taken out more than was good for her.
She began it that night, in the back room, when the others had gone to bed.
The candles in Salisbury Square were counted. Twelve guineas a month had to keep four people and pay the rent of two pair of stairs, and Clemency had counted the candles for three years, and knew to the half-inch what a night’s writing cost in tallow; and she had the June number of the Mortimers still to write, due at Baldwin’s on Wednesday, and not a line of it done. She lit the candle, and put the Mortimers on one side of the desk and Mr. Ricardo on the other, and meant to read him for a quarter of an hour, as a reward.
The first chapter was very hard.
It was about value, and it said that what a thing was worth to exchange depended on the labour it had taken to make, and not on what the labourer had been paid; and it said it in long sentences that went round a corner and came back, like a man explaining the way to somebody who is not listening. She read it slowly. She saw why Mr. Kinross had put his question mark where he had. She put her own beside it in her head, and went on, because she had promised to finish it, and she did not break promises to the man on the second bench.
The second chapter was called On Rent, and a few pages into it she sat up.
Thus suppose land, No. 1, 2, 3, to yield, with an equal employment of capital and labour, a net produce of 100, 90, and 80 quarters of corn.
She read it again. She took a sheet of old proof from the drawer, the wrong side of a page of her own fourth number, and wrote down No. 1, No. 2, No. 3 in a column, and 100, 90, 80 against them. Then she read on, and did what Mr. Ricardo told her: she let the people of his imaginary country increase, so that the best land was not enough to feed them, and they had to take No. 2 into cultivation; and she watched what happened to No. 1.
It began to pay rent. It paid ten quarters, because it was ten quarters better than the worst land anybody had to use. And when No. 3 was wanted, No. 1 paid twenty, and No. 2 paid ten; and the man who owned No. 1 had done nothing whatever to deserve either. The best field paid the difference between itself and the worst; and the difference grew with every poorer field that was wanted. Rent is always the difference, said Mr. Ricardo, as calmly as a man reading out the price of coals.
Clemency sat back.
She had read a good many books. She had read novels and sermons and the Edinburgh Review, and the whole of Emma twice in a week from the library on Ludgate Hill, and she had
liked a great many of them and loved a few. But nobody, in all her reading, had ever reasoned with her in figures. She had always had to put the figures in herself: to read that a gentleman had two thousand a year and work out on her fingers what his cook cost him, while the author went on about his eyes. Here was a man who thought as she did. He did not describe a thing and leave her to price it. He priced it first, and showed his working, and then he told her what it meant, and what it meant was true.
She went on. She did the sums on the back of the proof as she came to them, and they all came right, and every time one came right she felt it in her chest. She came to the place where he said that the landlord was doubly benefited by difficulty of production, and laughed aloud, alone in the back room at one in the morning; because she had always supposed, like everybody else, that dear bread was a misfortune to everybody; and Mr. Ricardo said that the landlord was paid twice over for it.
Below in the square the watchman called two o’clock, and a fine night, which it was not. She heard him without hearing him. She was at No. 3 by then, and the people of Mr. Ricardo’s country were eating their way down into poorer and poorer land, and every acre they were forced to take put a
little more into the pocket of a man who had done nothing but own the first acre; and she followed them down, field by field, into the dark.
The candle went down to its last inch. She looked at it, and at the clean sheet beside it on which the June Mortimers was not yet written, and did a short sum that had nothing to do with corn. Then she put the candle out, and sat on in the dark with the book shut on her knee, and her hand flat on it, as if it were warm.
Mr. Kinross went to the Albemarle’s office on the Tuesday morning, as he did whenever there was anything to be signed, and signed it; and then, instead of going home to Grosvenor Square, he crossed the street to Murray’s.
It was not a long way. It was about forty feet. He had crossed it perhaps a hundred times in eleven years, for the Quarterly and for nothing else. He went in, and asked for Mr. Ricardo’s Principles, and was given it, in grey boards, the same edition, and paid for it, and walked out with it under his arm, feeling exactly as he had felt at nine years old in Edinburgh on being sent back to learn a declension he had said he knew.
He did not buy a pencil.
He took it home, and shut himself in the library, and opened it at page one, and read the first chapter with no
pencil in his hand. It was quite as hard as it had been the year before. It went round its corners exactly as it had. But he read it now as he had never read it, because a young woman in Salisbury Square was reading it too, and had promised to finish it, and would.
He read the first chapter three times on the Tuesday, and once more on the Wednesday morning before breakfast, and on the fourth reading the sentence he had put his question mark against came apart in his hands, quite suddenly, like a knot when one has found the right end, and he understood it.
He sat for a while looking at it.
Lady Ardoch came down at ten and found him at the breakfast-table with Mr. Ricardo propped against the coffee-pot.
“Political economy,” she said, sitting down. “At breakfast. Your uncle read political economy once, in the year ninety-nine, when Mr. Pitt put on the tax upon incomes, and was cross for a twelvemonth.” She poured her tea. “Is she clever, Nathaniel?”
He turned a page.
“Cleverer than I am.”
“Then you had better finish the book,” said Lady Ardoch, “or she will, and you will have nothing to say at dinner for the rest of your life.” She buttered her toast. “Mrs. Berners called yesterday. She asked me whether you walked in the Temple
garden. I told her that you had walked there since you were one-and-twenty, which is true, and that you went to look at the river, which is what you told me. I should like to know, one day, which of us she believed.”
Then he remembered that the nineteenth number of the Warden was due at the office at noon, and that he had written none of it. He wrote it between breakfast and a quarter to twelve, at a speed that surprised him, about a siege of Ludlow that had never happened and the price of bread inside the walls. It was not the best number he had written. It had one sentence in it that he did not quite mean to put there, near the end, where the Warden lends Hugh of Clun a book of hours and observes that a book lent is the only gift a man may make a lady and be sure of seeing her again, because she must bring it back.
He sent it round by James, and did not read it over.
Toby was at Mr. Sass’s that Tuesday, as he was every Tuesday, drawing the foot.
It was a plaster foot, the cast of an antique one, and it had been on the table under the north window since Lady Day; and Toby had drawn it eleven times. The young gentlemen at the other tables, who were going to be Academicians, had drawn it twice
each and gone on to the Laocoön. They knew about the picture over the door. One of them, a tall youth with a stock up to his ears, said loudly that he had heard Tucker was hung on the line at last, the line being the cornice; and two of the others laughed, and the third did not, because he had been to look.
Toby went on drawing the foot.
Mr. Sass came round at four, as he always did, with his hands behind his back, and stood behind each of them for the length of a breath, and said one word or none. He stood behind Toby for longer. Then he leaned down and turned the cast a quarter round on its stand, so that the heel was towards the window and the toes away, as a foot is when the man it belongs to has turned to go.
“Now that one,” said Mr. Sass.
Toby drew it. He drew it till the light went, and walked home through Bloomsbury and Holborn with the board under his arm, thinking about the heel of a man who was walking away up a gravel path, and how the weight went down into it.
On the Thursday, at nine, when he carried the coals up the two pair of stairs to the Lydiards’ door, there was a paper parcel on top of the scuttle. It held a pound of mould candles. Mr. Dunning had allowed him a shilling a week since February, and he had been keeping it to buy colours of his own for
the summer. He had spent it on these. He had seen the light under the back-room door at one in the morning on the Monday, and on the Tuesday, coming down from the leads, where he went sometimes to look at the river; and he had seen Miss Lydiard’s candle-ends in the morning, in the dish on the landing, burnt down to nothing.
He set the scuttle down, and knocked, and came away.
Kit took the scuttle in, and found the parcel, and turned it over, and said, “Well, it wasn’t me,” with some regret; and Mrs. Lydiard looked at the candles, and at the stair, and kept her own counsel.
On Wednesday at a quarter to twelve Clemency delivered the fourteenth number of the Mortimers at Baldwin’s, at the warehouse stair, as she had since January, and was paid twelve guineas to the Author on delivery.
She had written it on the Tuesday night, by the last of the old candles, in one sitting, with Mr. Ricardo shut in the drawer so that she should not look at him. It was the best thing she had done since Christmas, and she knew it. Mr. Mortimer had been left standing on his own pavement at the end of the thirteenth number, looking up, and all the previous week she could not think what at. On the Tuesday night she saw: a gentleman across the way,
in a black coat, holding out a book on rent that he could not finish, and saying that he would like to know what was in it. She had written him down before she could stop herself. The fourteenth number was the story of Mr. Mortimer reading that book, and being told by Mr. Ricardo, in figures, that his house in Mount Street was worth what it was worth only because there were worse houses in Hanover Square. The gentleman had said it on a bench, to her, in the Temple garden; and now it would be on every breakfast-table in London on the first of June.
It was the fourth sentence she had taken from him. She did not pay for that one either.
Mr. Radcliffe read the first leaf standing, and did not smile.
“Your gentleman across the way,” he said. “Has he a name?”
“Mr. Mortimer does not ask it.”
“No. He would not.” Mr. Radcliffe put the leaf down. “You will want to know that there is nobody at the Chapter Coffee-house door this month.”
She waited.
“Mr. Hindley went north on Monday by the Manchester mail,” said Mr. Radcliffe. “I am told the house in Mosley Street has stopped. Hindley and Son.” He looked at her over his spectacles. “I tell you because Mr. Hindley has been telling the Row since
October that he writes the Mortimers. He will not be telling it in Manchester. You may deliver at the front door next month, if you like.”
It was Mr. Hindley, the son of the Manchester house, who had sat in the Chapter Coffee-house on every delivery day since Christmas, watching Paternoster Row to see who brought the Mortimers in; and it was because of him that she had gone up the warehouse stair at Baldwin’s since January, and not in at the door. She went home by Ludgate Hill with the twelve guineas in her glove and the house in Mosley Street in her head. Mr. Radcliffe did not know, and she had never told him, that the same house owed her mother four hundred pounds.
The letter came on the Thursday, from Mr. Pocock in Bread Street, who had been her father’s attorney and was now attorney to very few people, to Mrs. Lydiard. It ran to four close pages. Messrs Hindley and Son of Manchester, merchants, had stopped payment, and a commission of bankruptcy was expected to issue against them within the month. The creditors would then be called upon to prove their debts. Mr. Pocock had the honour to remind Mrs. Lydiard of the loan the late Mr. Lydiard had made to the elder Mr. Hindley, which young Mr. Hindley’s promise in October, very properly written down at the time, had
kept alive. Mrs. Lydiard would prove it; and to prove it, Mr. Pocock would require the late Mr. Lydiard’s books.
Mrs. Lydiard read it twice, and gave it to her elder daughter, and went to the window.
“They are in the trunk,” she said. “Under your bed. All of them.”
Clemency had gone over the Bread Street accounts more often than her mother liked: the debts, the composition, what had been owed and to whom. But those were her own sheets, made afterwards. Her father’s books she had not opened since Bread Street. She knelt on the boards that night, with Lucy asleep, and lifted the lid, and there they were, as the bailiffs had left them because nobody would give anything for them: six ledgers in green vellum, and a cash-book, and a bill-book, lettered on the spines in her father’s hand, the years running from 1804 to 1817. She found the year eleven, and the page, and the line: Hindley, Jno., Manchester, by loan, £400. Her father had written it very large and clear, as a man writes when he is quite sure he will be paid.
She turned a few pages on, without meaning to. The hand went smaller as the year went on. By the autumn of the year sixteen it was smaller than she had ever seen it, and the entries were very close together, and a great many
of them began Bill drawn. She read down them as she had read down Mr. Ricardo’s fields, and saw what they were: each bill drawn to meet the one before it, and each a little larger; a man borrowing in order to repay, and calling it trade.
She shut the book.
She left it shut that night. But she knelt a long while on the boards with her hand flat on the green vellum, as she had sat on the Monday with her hand on Mr. Ricardo; and it came to her, without her wishing it, that she could read it now. She had not been able to read it in Bread Street, at three-and-twenty, when it mattered. She could read it now, when it no longer mattered at all; and she did not know whether that was the cruellest thing she had ever found out or only the most interesting.
In the morning her mother asked, over the kettle, without turning round, whether she had found it.
“Yes, Mamma.”
“Was it in his hand?”
“Yes. Very large.”
Mrs. Lydiard set the kettle on the fire.
“He always wrote large,” she said, “when he was sure.” And that was all she said; but she went about the room for the rest of the morning a little more slowly than usual, touching things.
Kit came home on the Friday with the Temple.
“You’ll never guess,” he said, “who has been seen in the garden.”
Nobody guessed. Lucy said the King, because she always did.
“Kinross!” said Kit. “On the bench by the river, Monday afternoon, with the governess. The same one, Pelham says, from the Academy. He’s taken her up. Grice says he has engaged her for his aunt. Pelham says nonsense, he was reading to her out of a book on rent, which is the cruellest thing Pelham ever heard of a man doing to a woman.” Kit helped himself to bread. “And Mrs. Berners has it from her husband, who has it from Pelham, that a gentleman who has been refused by Miss Lauder has no business consoling himself in the Temple with a governess six weeks after; and Brook Street, Mrs. Berners says, will not stand it.”
There was a short pause.
“What will Brook Street do?” said Mrs. Lydiard.
“Watch,” said Kit, with relish. “That’s what Brook Street does.” He turned to his sister. “You saw her, Clem, at the Academy. What’s she like?”
“Plain,” said Clemency, “and badly dressed, and too old for a governess.”
Kit was satisfied. Lucy looked at her sister’s gown, which was dyed, and
then at her plate, and said nothing; she was learning.
Clemency cut her bread into four, very exactly, and ate one of the pieces.
She had said last Saturday, on the second bench, that Brook Street did not come into the Temple. It was true. She had forgotten that the Temple had a Brook Street of its own, and that it dined in Hall every day at five, and that Kit carried its conversation home in his pocket with Mr. Pelham’s magazines.
On the Saturday she did not go to the second bench.
She came down the gravel from the gate at twenty past three, as before, and passed the second bench, where Mr. Kinross was sitting with a book he was not reading; and she went on, without a glance, to the river wall, where Toby was, and sat down on the coping beside him, with a whole yard of stone between them, and took out her work.
Toby moved up to make room, though there was room already, and went on drawing.
It was six yards from the river wall to the second bench, across the walk. A man sitting on the bench and a young woman sitting on the wall, looking at the river, were two people who happened to be in a public garden at the same hour on a Saturday; and an old Bencher, or Mr. Grice, or a friend
of Mr. Berners, might walk between them up and down the gravel the whole afternoon and see nothing whatever. They spoke low, when they spoke, and to the river; and the tide coming up against the wall covered a great deal.
“The Inn has seen us,” said Mr. Kinross, after a while.
“Mr. Grice says you have engaged me for your aunt.”
“My aunt would like that very much.”
“Mr. Pelham says you read to me out of a book on rent, which is the cruellest thing he ever heard of.”
“Mr. Pelham,” said Mr. Kinross, “has never read it.” He was silent a moment. “Six yards.”
“Until July.”
“Until July,” he agreed, and something in the way he said it made her look down at her work.
The tide was making. A lighterman went up under the wall, standing to his sweep, and looked at the young person on the coping, and at the boy, and at nothing else, and was gone.
“I have read the chapter on rent,” said Clemency.
“Have you.”
“It is the first book I ever read that reasons in sums. All the others make me do the sums myself.” She was looking at the river. “He has three fields, and he numbers them, and he makes them feed a country, and he
shows his working at every step; and every step comes right. I did them all on the back of a proof. It was like being spoken to in my own language by somebody who had never heard me speak it.”
He said nothing for so long that she thought she had offended him; and she turned her head, for the first time that afternoon, and looked at him across the gravel.
He was not offended. He was looking at the grey book on the bench beside him; and she saw that it was not her book, which was in Salisbury Square in the drawer of her desk. It was another. It was the same, in the same grey boards, with the label new and white, and a slip of paper standing out of it near the front.
“You bought another,” she said.
“On Tuesday.” He did not look up.
“Why?”
“Because you will finish it,” said Mr. Kinross, “and I was not prepared to have nothing to say.” He opened it at the slip. “He says here that the value of a thing depends on the labour it took to make, and not on what the man who made it was paid. I put a question against that last year. I have taken the question away.” He shut the book again. “By that reckoning, the Warden is worth a good deal more than it fetches. I have never been paid a farthing for it.”
“Nor will you be,” said Clemency, “if you go on giving it away.”
He laughed; and then he was quiet, and when he spoke again it was in another voice, the one she had heard once across a picture in the Great Room, when he forgot to look cast down.
“His three fields,” he said. “No. 1, No. 2 and No. 3. They are very good fields. But nobody in them has ever died.”
She looked at him.
“In the year 1348,” said Mr. Kinross, “the pestilence came to England, and in two years it killed a third of the people who worked the land, or more. Mr. Ricardo’s sum would say that No. 3 went out of cultivation, and then No. 2, and the rent of No. 1 fell to nothing. So it did. And the King, and the lords of all the No. 1s in England, made an ordinance, and then a statute, to say that a labourer must take the wages he had taken before the pestilence, and not a penny more, and might be put in the stocks for demanding more. They could not alter the sum. So they altered the law.” He turned the grey book over in his hands. “Thirty years after, the men with the low wages came up Fish Street Hill and burnt the Savoy. That is my fourteenth century. It is the only arithmetic I know.”
The river went by under the wall. Clemency sat still on the coping with
her needle in her hand.
She had read the Warden for a year and a half, and loved it, and quarrelled with it in her head, and taken his sentences. She had read it for its prices from the first: the Warden standing in a kitchen, looked at by people who knew to a penny what he cost. But she had never thought it had a sum of its own. It had kings in it, and castles, and the March, and a man who kept a gate. She saw now, all at once, that it had had a sum in it all the while; and that he had seen the sum, and put it in, and never shown his working.
And yet it was no answer. Mr. Ricardo’s sum was still right. The statute had not made it wrong; it had only made it cruel. She was moved, and she was not persuaded.
“Mr. Ricardo,” she said slowly, “says that corn is not high because a rent is paid, but a rent is paid because corn is high. Your lords made a law to keep the wages down when the sum had turned against them. That is not an answer to him. It is a proof of him. The law failed; and they burnt the Savoy.” She stopped. “And I have not yet come to his chapter on wages. When I have, I shall answer you properly.”
“It failed,” said Mr. Kinross. “It was also the law, and men sat in the stocks under it while it was failing. Your sums come right, Miss Lydiard. Mine are the
people who had to live while they were coming right.”
Toby put in the line of a barge’s mast, and never looked round.
She sat on the wall with her work in her lap and did not sew a stitch of it. She had been given things all her life, and had paid for every one. But nobody, in six-and-twenty years, had ever gone after her into a book.
That night she began the next chapter, which was called On the Rent
of Mines. It was brief. It said that a mine paid rent on the same principle as a field: because it was richer than the poorest mine that anybody was obliged to work.
She had never in her life been nearer a coal-pit than the coal-merchant’s on Puddle Dock, and she did not know yet that there was coal at Ardoch. She did a sum in the margin of her proof, and it came right, and she went to bed.
(To be continued.)
THE WIT OF MOUNT STREET;
or,
HER HEART IN NUMBERS.
(Continued from page 284.)
CHAPTER XV.
On Value.
In which a book is lent and not given, three fields are made to feed a country, a gentleman crosses forty feet of Albemarle Street, a house in Manchester stops, and the pestilence is called as a witness.
On the Monday he brought a book.
He had it on the bench beside him when she came down the gravel from the gate, at twenty past three, in the dyed gown: a fat octavo in grey boards, the paper label rubbed, with a sharp edge of white slips standing out of the top of it like teeth. He left it where it lay when she sat down, and she appeared not to look at it. Toby, on the coping of the river wall with his back to the two of them, had already taken out his own book and was drawing the water; and for some time the three of them sat in the Inner Temple garden and attended to their several occupations, as people do who have met in a public place by chance.
“You are looking at my book,” said Mr. Kinross.
“I am looking at the river.”
“You are looking at my book out of the side of your bonnet. It is a thing I have learnt to see.” He laid his hand on it. “It is the only book from Albemarle Street that I have never been able to finish.”
“From your Albemarle Street?”
“From the other side of it. The Albemarle’s door is on one side of the street, and Mr. Murray’s is on the other. This is Murray’s.” He turned it so that she could read the label. Principles of Political Economy and Taxation. “By Mr. Ricardo. The second edition. I bought it at Hatchard’s last winter, because everybody at the Temple was quarrelling about it at dinner, and I like to know what a man is being abused for before I abuse him. I read the first chapter. I read it three times. On the third time I made a
mark in the margin, and the mark was a question; and I have not opened it since.”
“What were they quarrelling about?”
“Corn,” said Mr. Kinross. “Whether the price of bread in London is kept up for the sake of the landlords, and whether that is wicked or merely Tory. Pelham says Mr. Ricardo has proved that every landlord in England is a thief. Mr. Grice says he has proved nothing of the kind, and that he is a stockbroker. I did not get far enough to know which of them was right.” He considered the river. “I am a landlord myself, in Scotland, in what I believe is a small way. I have never looked. I found I did not want to know very much.”
“Then why have you brought it?”
He was silent a moment.
“Because you will finish it,” he said. “And I should like to know what is in it.”
She took it then. It was heavier than it looked. She opened it at the first chapter, which was called On Value, and saw his pencil going down the margin of the first pages: a stroke here, a tick there, a word she could not read. She had watched that pencil move once, in August, on a bench, and had never seen what it wrote. On the twentieth page the marks thinned. On the twenty-second there was a single question mark, small and upright, against a sentence about the labour bestowed on commodities; and after that the margins were clean.
She thought of his pencil. He had given it to Toby on the river wall in March, and Toby had told her what Mr. Kinross said when he gave it: that he had done marking things. She kept the thought to herself.
“You may keep it,” said Mr. Kinross.
“No.”
“I have no use for it. I have proved that.”
“Lend it me,” said Clemency. “I will give it back. I do not take presents, Mr. Kinross. I have never been able to afford them.”
He looked at her, and the place at the corner of his mouth moved: the place she had once laid her mother’s carmine on, in a drawing of his face, and been ashamed of for a week.
“Lend it, then,” he said. “For as long as you like. I shall not ask for it.”
“You will ask for it,” said Clemency, “the day I have finished it, because you will want to know whether I agree with him. And I shall tell you.”
She put it under her arm with the London. It made her lean a little to one side going back up the gravel, and the old Bencher, who was coming down it, observed that the young person had been to a library and taken out more than was good for her.
She began it that night, in the back room, when the others had gone to bed.
The candles in Salisbury Square were counted. Twelve guineas a month had to keep four people and pay the rent of two pair of stairs, and Clemency had counted the candles for three years, and knew to the half-inch what a night’s writing cost in tallow; and she had the June number of the Mortimers still to write, due at Baldwin’s on Wednesday, and not a line of it done. She lit the candle, and put the Mortimers on one side of the desk and Mr. Ricardo on the other, and meant to read him for a quarter of an hour, as a reward.
The first chapter was very hard.
It was about value, and it said that what a thing was worth to exchange depended on the labour it had taken to make, and not on what the labourer had been paid; and it said it in long sentences that went round a corner and came back, like a man explaining the way to somebody who is not listening. She read it slowly. She saw why Mr. Kinross had put his question mark where he had. She put her own beside it in her head, and went on, because she had promised to finish it, and she did not break promises to the man on the second bench.
The second chapter was called On Rent, and a few pages into it she sat up.
Thus suppose land, No. 1, 2, 3, to yield, with an equal employment of capital and labour, a net produce of 100, 90, and 80 quarters of corn.
She read it again. She took a sheet of old proof from the drawer, the wrong side of a page of her own fourth number, and wrote down No. 1, No. 2, No. 3 in a column, and 100, 90, 80 against them. Then she read on, and did what Mr. Ricardo told her: she let the people of his imaginary country increase, so that the best land was not enough to feed them, and they had to take No. 2 into cultivation; and she watched what happened to No. 1.
It began to pay rent. It paid ten quarters, because it was ten quarters better than the worst land anybody had to use. And when No. 3 was wanted, No. 1 paid twenty, and No. 2 paid ten; and the man who owned No. 1 had done nothing whatever to deserve either. The best field paid the difference between itself and the worst; and the difference grew with every poorer field that was wanted. Rent is always the difference, said Mr. Ricardo, as calmly as a man reading out the price of coals.
Clemency sat back.
She had read a good many books. She had read novels and sermons and the Edinburgh Review, and the whole of Emma twice in a week from the library on Ludgate Hill, and she had
liked a great many of them and loved a few. But nobody, in all her reading, had ever reasoned with her in figures. She had always had to put the figures in herself: to read that a gentleman had two thousand a year and work out on her fingers what his cook cost him, while the author went on about his eyes. Here was a man who thought as she did. He did not describe a thing and leave her to price it. He priced it first, and showed his working, and then he told her what it meant, and what it meant was true.
She went on. She did the sums on the back of the proof as she came to them, and they all came right, and every time one came right she felt it in her chest. She came to the place where he said that the landlord was doubly benefited by difficulty of production, and laughed aloud, alone in the back room at one in the morning; because she had always supposed, like everybody else, that dear bread was a misfortune to everybody; and Mr. Ricardo said that the landlord was paid twice over for it.
Below in the square the watchman called two o’clock, and a fine night, which it was not. She heard him without hearing him. She was at No. 3 by then, and the people of Mr. Ricardo’s country were eating their way down into poorer and poorer land, and every acre they were forced to take put a little more into the pocket of a man who had done nothing but own the first acre; and she followed them down, field by field, into the dark.
The candle went down to its last inch. She looked at it, and at the clean sheet beside it on which the June Mortimers was not yet written, and did a short sum that had nothing to do with corn. Then she put the candle out, and sat on in the dark with the book shut on her knee, and her hand flat on it, as if it were warm.
Mr. Kinross went to the Albemarle’s office on the Tuesday morning, as he did whenever there was anything to be signed, and signed it; and then, instead of going home to Grosvenor Square, he crossed the street to Murray’s.
It was not a long way. It was about forty feet. He had crossed it perhaps a hundred times in eleven years, for the Quarterly and for nothing else. He went in, and asked for Mr. Ricardo’s Principles, and was given it, in grey boards, the same edition, and paid for it, and walked out with it under his arm, feeling exactly as he had felt at nine years old in Edinburgh on being sent back to learn a declension he had said he knew.
He did not buy a pencil.
He took it home, and shut himself in the library, and opened it at page one, and read the first chapter with no
pencil in his hand. It was quite as hard as it had been the year before. It went round its corners exactly as it had. But he read it now as he had never read it, because a young woman in Salisbury Square was reading it too, and had promised to finish it, and would.
He read the first chapter three times on the Tuesday, and once more on the Wednesday morning before breakfast, and on the fourth reading the sentence he had put his question mark against came apart in his hands, quite suddenly, like a knot when one has found the right end, and he understood it.
He sat for a while looking at it.
Lady Ardoch came down at ten and found him at the breakfast-table with Mr. Ricardo propped against the coffee-pot.
“Political economy,” she said, sitting down. “At breakfast. Your uncle read political economy once, in the year ninety-nine, when Mr. Pitt put on the tax upon incomes, and was cross for a twelvemonth.” She poured her tea. “Is she clever, Nathaniel?”
He turned a page.
“Cleverer than I am.”
“Then you had better finish the book,” said Lady Ardoch, “or she will, and you will have nothing to say at dinner for the rest of your life.” She buttered her toast. “Mrs. Berners called yesterday. She asked me whether you walked in the Temple garden. I told her that you had walked there since you were one-and-twenty, which is true, and that you went to look at the river, which is what you told me. I should like to know, one day, which of us she believed.”
Then he remembered that the nineteenth number of the Warden was due at the office at noon, and that he had written none of it. He wrote it between breakfast and a quarter to twelve, at a speed that surprised him, about a siege of Ludlow that had never happened and the price of bread inside the walls. It was not the best number he had written. It had one sentence in it that he did not quite mean to put there, near the end, where the Warden lends Hugh of Clun a book of hours and observes that a book lent is the only gift a man may make a lady and be sure of seeing her again, because she must bring it back.
He sent it round by James, and did not read it over.
Toby was at Mr. Sass’s that Tuesday, as he was every Tuesday, drawing the foot.
It was a plaster foot, the cast of an antique one, and it had been on the table under the north window since Lady Day; and Toby had drawn it eleven times. The young gentlemen at the other tables, who were going to be Academicians, had drawn it twice
each and gone on to the Laocoön. They knew about the picture over the door. One of them, a tall youth with a stock up to his ears, said loudly that he had heard Tucker was hung on the line at last, the line being the cornice; and two of the others laughed, and the third did not, because he had been to look.
Toby went on drawing the foot.
Mr. Sass came round at four, as he always did, with his hands behind his back, and stood behind each of them for the length of a breath, and said one word or none. He stood behind Toby for longer. Then he leaned down and turned the cast a quarter round on its stand, so that the heel was towards the window and the toes away, as a foot is when the man it belongs to has turned to go.
“Now that one,” said Mr. Sass.
Toby drew it. He drew it till the light went, and walked home through Bloomsbury and Holborn with the board under his arm, thinking about the heel of a man who was walking away up a gravel path, and how the weight went down into it.
On the Thursday, at nine, when he carried the coals up the two pair of stairs to the Lydiards’ door, there was a paper parcel on top of the scuttle. It held a pound of mould candles. Mr. Dunning had allowed him a shilling a week since February, and he had been keeping it to buy colours of his own for the summer. He had spent it on these. He had seen the light under the back-room door at one in the morning on the Monday, and on the Tuesday, coming down from the leads, where he went sometimes to look at the river; and he had seen Miss Lydiard’s candle-ends in the morning, in the dish on the landing, burnt down to nothing.
He set the scuttle down, and knocked, and came away.
Kit took the scuttle in, and found the parcel, and turned it over, and said, “Well, it wasn’t me,” with some regret; and Mrs. Lydiard looked at the candles, and at the stair, and kept her own counsel.
On Wednesday at a quarter to twelve Clemency delivered the fourteenth number of the Mortimers at Baldwin’s, at the warehouse stair, as she had since January, and was paid twelve guineas to the Author on delivery.
She had written it on the Tuesday night, by the last of the old candles, in one sitting, with Mr. Ricardo shut in the drawer so that she should not look at him. It was the best thing she had done since Christmas, and she knew it. Mr. Mortimer had been left standing on his own pavement at the end of the thirteenth number, looking up, and all the previous week she could not think what at. On the Tuesday night she saw: a gentleman across the way,
in a black coat, holding out a book on rent that he could not finish, and saying that he would like to know what was in it. She had written him down before she could stop herself. The fourteenth number was the story of Mr. Mortimer reading that book, and being told by Mr. Ricardo, in figures, that his house in Mount Street was worth what it was worth only because there were worse houses in Hanover Square. The gentleman had said it on a bench, to her, in the Temple garden; and now it would be on every breakfast-table in London on the first of June.
It was the fourth sentence she had taken from him. She did not pay for that one either.
Mr. Radcliffe read the first leaf standing, and did not smile.
“Your gentleman across the way,” he said. “Has he a name?”
“Mr. Mortimer does not ask it.”
“No. He would not.” Mr. Radcliffe put the leaf down. “You will want to know that there is nobody at the Chapter Coffee-house door this month.”
She waited.
“Mr. Hindley went north on Monday by the Manchester mail,” said Mr. Radcliffe. “I am told the house in Mosley Street has stopped. Hindley and Son.” He looked at her over his spectacles. “I tell you because Mr. Hindley has been telling the Row since October that he writes the Mortimers. He will not be telling it in Manchester. You may deliver at the front door next month, if you like.”
It was Mr. Hindley, the son of the Manchester house, who had sat in the Chapter Coffee-house on every delivery day since Christmas, watching Paternoster Row to see who brought the Mortimers in; and it was because of him that she had gone up the warehouse stair at Baldwin’s since January, and not in at the door. She went home by Ludgate Hill with the twelve guineas in her glove and the house in Mosley Street in her head. Mr. Radcliffe did not know, and she had never told him, that the same house owed her mother four hundred pounds.
The letter came on the Thursday, from Mr. Pocock in Bread Street, who had been her father’s attorney and was now attorney to very few people, to Mrs. Lydiard. It ran to four close pages. Messrs Hindley and Son of Manchester, merchants, had stopped payment, and a commission of bankruptcy was expected to issue against them within the month. The creditors would then be called upon to prove their debts. Mr. Pocock had the honour to remind Mrs. Lydiard of the loan the late Mr. Lydiard had made to the elder Mr. Hindley, which young Mr. Hindley’s promise in October, very properly written down at the time, had
kept alive. Mrs. Lydiard would prove it; and to prove it, Mr. Pocock would require the late Mr. Lydiard’s books.
Mrs. Lydiard read it twice, and gave it to her elder daughter, and went to the window.
“They are in the trunk,” she said. “Under your bed. All of them.”
Clemency had gone over the Bread Street accounts more often than her mother liked: the debts, the composition, what had been owed and to whom. But those were her own sheets, made afterwards. Her father’s books she had not opened since Bread Street. She knelt on the boards that night, with Lucy asleep, and lifted the lid, and there they were, as the bailiffs had left them because nobody would give anything for them: six ledgers in green vellum, and a cash-book, and a bill-book, lettered on the spines in her father’s hand, the years running from 1804 to 1817. She found the year eleven, and the page, and the line: Hindley, Jno., Manchester, by loan, £400. Her father had written it very large and clear, as a man writes when he is quite sure he will be paid.
She turned a few pages on, without meaning to. The hand went smaller as the year went on. By the autumn of the year sixteen it was smaller than she had ever seen it, and the entries were very close together, and a great many of them began Bill drawn. She read down them as she had read down Mr. Ricardo’s fields, and saw what they were: each bill drawn to meet the one before it, and each a little larger; a man borrowing in order to repay, and calling it trade.
She shut the book.
She left it shut that night. But she knelt a long while on the boards with her hand flat on the green vellum, as she had sat on the Monday with her hand on Mr. Ricardo; and it came to her, without her wishing it, that she could read it now. She had not been able to read it in Bread Street, at three-and-twenty, when it mattered. She could read it now, when it no longer mattered at all; and she did not know whether that was the cruellest thing she had ever found out or only the most interesting.
In the morning her mother asked, over the kettle, without turning round, whether she had found it.
“Yes, Mamma.”
“Was it in his hand?”
“Yes. Very large.”
Mrs. Lydiard set the kettle on the fire.
“He always wrote large,” she said, “when he was sure.” And that was all she said; but she went about the room for the rest of the morning a little more slowly than usual, touching things.
Kit came home on the Friday with the Temple.
“You’ll never guess,” he said, “who has been seen in the garden.”
Nobody guessed. Lucy said the King, because she always did.
“Kinross!” said Kit. “On the bench by the river, Monday afternoon, with the governess. The same one, Pelham says, from the Academy. He’s taken her up. Grice says he has engaged her for his aunt. Pelham says nonsense, he was reading to her out of a book on rent, which is the cruellest thing Pelham ever heard of a man doing to a woman.” Kit helped himself to bread. “And Mrs. Berners has it from her husband, who has it from Pelham, that a gentleman who has been refused by Miss Lauder has no business consoling himself in the Temple with a governess six weeks after; and Brook Street, Mrs. Berners says, will not stand it.”
There was a short pause.
“What will Brook Street do?” said Mrs. Lydiard.
“Watch,” said Kit, with relish. “That’s what Brook Street does.” He turned to his sister. “You saw her, Clem, at the Academy. What’s she like?”
“Plain,” said Clemency, “and badly dressed, and too old for a governess.”
Kit was satisfied. Lucy looked at her sister’s gown, which was dyed, and then at her plate, and said nothing; she was learning.
Clemency cut her bread into four, very exactly, and ate one of the pieces.
She had said last Saturday, on the second bench, that Brook Street did not come into the Temple. It was true. She had forgotten that the Temple had a Brook Street of its own, and that it dined in Hall every day at five, and that Kit carried its conversation home in his pocket with Mr. Pelham’s magazines.
On the Saturday she did not go to the second bench.
She came down the gravel from the gate at twenty past three, as before, and passed the second bench, where Mr. Kinross was sitting with a book he was not reading; and she went on, without a glance, to the river wall, where Toby was, and sat down on the coping beside him, with a whole yard of stone between them, and took out her work.
Toby moved up to make room, though there was room already, and went on drawing.
It was six yards from the river wall to the second bench, across the walk. A man sitting on the bench and a young woman sitting on the wall, looking at the river, were two people who happened to be in a public garden at the same hour on a Saturday; and an old Bencher, or Mr. Grice, or a friend
of Mr. Berners, might walk between them up and down the gravel the whole afternoon and see nothing whatever. They spoke low, when they spoke, and to the river; and the tide coming up against the wall covered a great deal.
“The Inn has seen us,” said Mr. Kinross, after a while.
“Mr. Grice says you have engaged me for your aunt.”
“My aunt would like that very much.”
“Mr. Pelham says you read to me out of a book on rent, which is the cruellest thing he ever heard of.”
“Mr. Pelham,” said Mr. Kinross, “has never read it.” He was silent a moment. “Six yards.”
“Until July.”
“Until July,” he agreed, and something in the way he said it made her look down at her work.
The tide was making. A lighterman went up under the wall, standing to his sweep, and looked at the young person on the coping, and at the boy, and at nothing else, and was gone.
“I have read the chapter on rent,” said Clemency.
“Have you.”
“It is the first book I ever read that reasons in sums. All the others make me do the sums myself.” She was looking at the river. “He has three fields, and he numbers them, and he makes them feed a country, and he shows his working at every step; and every step comes right. I did them all on the back of a proof. It was like being spoken to in my own language by somebody who had never heard me speak it.”
He said nothing for so long that she thought she had offended him; and she turned her head, for the first time that afternoon, and looked at him across the gravel.
He was not offended. He was looking at the grey book on the bench beside him; and she saw that it was not her book, which was in Salisbury Square in the drawer of her desk. It was another. It was the same, in the same grey boards, with the label new and white, and a slip of paper standing out of it near the front.
“You bought another,” she said.
“On Tuesday.” He did not look up.
“Why?”
“Because you will finish it,” said Mr. Kinross, “and I was not prepared to have nothing to say.” He opened it at the slip. “He says here that the value of a thing depends on the labour it took to make, and not on what the man who made it was paid. I put a question against that last year. I have taken the question away.” He shut the book again. “By that reckoning, the Warden is worth a good deal more than it fetches. I have never been paid a farthing for it.”
“Nor will you be,” said Clemency, “if you go on giving it away.”
He laughed; and then he was quiet, and when he spoke again it was in another voice, the one she had heard once across a picture in the Great Room, when he forgot to look cast down.
“His three fields,” he said. “No. 1, No. 2 and No. 3. They are very good fields. But nobody in them has ever died.”
She looked at him.
“In the year 1348,” said Mr. Kinross, “the pestilence came to England, and in two years it killed a third of the people who worked the land, or more. Mr. Ricardo’s sum would say that No. 3 went out of cultivation, and then No. 2, and the rent of No. 1 fell to nothing. So it did. And the King, and the lords of all the No. 1s in England, made an ordinance, and then a statute, to say that a labourer must take the wages he had taken before the pestilence, and not a penny more, and might be put in the stocks for demanding more. They could not alter the sum. So they altered the law.” He turned the grey book over in his hands. “Thirty years after, the men with the low wages came up Fish Street Hill and burnt the Savoy. That is my fourteenth century. It is the only arithmetic I know.”
The river went by under the wall. Clemency sat still on the coping with her needle in her hand.
She had read the Warden for a year and a half, and loved it, and quarrelled with it in her head, and taken his sentences. She had read it for its prices from the first: the Warden standing in a kitchen, looked at by people who knew to a penny what he cost. But she had never thought it had a sum of its own. It had kings in it, and castles, and the March, and a man who kept a gate. She saw now, all at once, that it had had a sum in it all the while; and that he had seen the sum, and put it in, and never shown his working.
And yet it was no answer. Mr. Ricardo’s sum was still right. The statute had not made it wrong; it had only made it cruel. She was moved, and she was not persuaded.
“Mr. Ricardo,” she said slowly, “says that corn is not high because a rent is paid, but a rent is paid because corn is high. Your lords made a law to keep the wages down when the sum had turned against them. That is not an answer to him. It is a proof of him. The law failed; and they burnt the Savoy.” She stopped. “And I have not yet come to his chapter on wages. When I have, I shall answer you properly.”
“It failed,” said Mr. Kinross. “It was also the law, and men sat in the stocks under it while it was failing. Your sums come right, Miss Lydiard. Mine are the
people who had to live while they were coming right.”
Toby put in the line of a barge’s mast, and never looked round.
She sat on the wall with her work in her lap and did not sew a stitch of it. She had been given things all her life, and had paid for every one. But nobody, in six-and-twenty years, had ever gone after her into a book.
That night she began the next chapter, which was called On the Rent of Mines. It was brief. It said that a mine paid rent on the same principle as a field: because it was richer than the poorest mine that anybody was obliged to work.
She had never in her life been nearer a coal-pit than the coal-merchant’s on Puddle Dock, and she did not know yet that there was coal at Ardoch. She did a sum in the margin of her proof, and it came right, and she went to bed.
(To be continued.)
Edited by Michael Cummins. Written in full collaboration with Anthropic’s Claude models, and set here as it might have appeared in a London magazine of 1820. Read the announcement, with the plan of London.
A Young Lady at Islington asks what is a Bencher. He is one of the elder members of an Inn of Court, who govern it, dine at the high table, and walk in its garden as if they owned it, which they do. They are not, as our Correspondent supposes, the gentlemen who sit on the benches.
A Country Gentleman asks what is meant by a picture’s being hung on the line. The line is the height of a man’s eye, where a picture can be seen without a glass or a stiff neck. The places on it go to the Academicians, and to the President’s friends, and very seldom to a boy of fourteen.
A Reader at Gravesend asks what a wherry is. It is the long light boat in which the watermen row passengers up and down the river and across it, a sixpence or a shilling the fare, and a great deal of advice thrown in.
A Visitor from the North asks why there should be stables at Charing Cross. The King’s Mews has stood there since the King’s falcons were mewed in it, which is to say, moulted; it has been stables for two hundred years, and keeps the name.
A Lady in Brook Street asks where Brook Street goes in July. To the country; to Brighton; to Tunbridge Wells, to drink the water and forget whatever it was talking of in May. We do not think our Correspondent need be uneasy. It will be talking of something else by August.
A Mother of Daughters asks what a governess is paid. From twenty to forty pounds a year in a good family, with her board and the schoolroom fire; and she is expected to know French, and the globes, and when to leave the room.
A wager laid in the Inner Temple on a wedding by Midsummer is noticed. We decline to hold the stakes.
A Gentleman who signs himself Vindex asks whether a lie that was never told can be said to have been kept. It can. Ask any lady in Brook Street.

